One of the most common questions I’ve encountered in my 25-plus years covering consumer credit is: “What credit card should I get based on my lifestyle?” I appreciate this question because it shows a thoughtful approach to choosing the right card.
The short answer is that there is no “one-size-fits-all” when it comes to choosing the best credit card. Simply put, aligning your lifestyle and spending patterns with a prospective new card is the most savvy way to comparison shop.
The goal of this primer is straightforward- to boost your confidence when getting your next credit card (whether you’re new to credit or wanting to replace a card in your wallet with one that is more compelling). Doing a few minutes of homework on the front-end can help ensure that you maximize the benefits of your new card, and it’s important to carefully evaluate your options before applying for a new credit card to ensure you select the one that best fits your needs, credit score, and desired rewards. This, in turn, should make you a much more satisfied cardholder in the long run.
Start with your lifestyle and spending patterns
Track your monthly expenses
While it’s not something that many folks enjoy doing, tracking your expenses is vital not just from a budgeting standpoint, but also in order to help you find the best credit card.
“Before comparing cards, take time to really look at where your money goes each month,” suggests Megan Daniels, a travel writer and founder of JourneyCurrencies.com. “Most people can name a few of their big expenses, but the smaller, everyday spending often tells the real story. Tracking for even a short time can be eye-opening. This insight helps you choose a card that actually fits your spending — not the version of your spending you think you have.”
Identify your top spending categories
To maximize your potential earnings, most notably with reward credit cards, it’s important to first identify your top spending categories.
“An easy way to get an overview of your spending is with your credit card or bank statements,” advises Gerri Detweiler, credit and small business expert and coauthor of “Finance Your Own Business: Get on the Financing Fast Track.” “Most financial institutions make it easy to download your transactions, and when you do, they will often already be categorized with the type of spend; groceries or pharmacy, for example.”
Some rewards credit cards offer extra points or cash back in certain categories like groceries, gas, or travel, so identifying your top spending areas can help you take full advantage of these bonus categories and maximize your card’s rewards.
Daniels adds that “after tracking, the right kind of card often becomes obvious. If most of your budget goes toward groceries, gas, or travel, look for cards that reward those categories such as a gas rebate card. A good card should work with your existing habits – not push you to spend more just to earn something back.”
Use tools to analyze your habits
Fortunately, there are many handy tools available today that can greatly assist you in tracking your spending.
Daniels opines that “you don’t need anything complicated. A simple Google Sheet, a budgeting app, or even your bank’s built-in spending tracker can show you exactly where your money goes.
“Once you see the numbers, think about how much effort you want to put into managing your rewards (more on this below). Different rewards programs require varying levels of management and can be tailored to your spending habits and lifestyle preferences.
“Some people prefer simple cash back rewards, while others don’t mind keeping up with categories to earn more points. Find the balance between ease and effort that works for you – something simple enough to keep up with, but rewarding enough to feel worth it.”
Also, seek to leverage the latest technology. Detweiler recommends an AI tool like ChatGPT. Just be very careful not to share personal information like account numbers.
Choose the right card type for your goals
Build credit: Secured and student credit cards
If your goal is to establish or rebuild your credit, options include a secured credit card, a low-limit card such as a student credit card, or a credit builder account. All of these are excellent choices to begin establishing your credit record with the three major credit bureaus and are considered credit-building cards.
Secured and student credit cards are especially well-suited for individuals with limited credit history or those with bad credit looking to rebuild. These cards typically have more flexible requirements than traditional credit cards.
- A secured credit card requires a security deposit that acts as collateral and sets your credit limit. Traditional unsecured cards do not require a deposit.
- A student credit card can be an effective way to establish credit while you are in school (age 18 or older). They are tailored for college students, often come with a low initial credit limit, and may have no annual fees.
Whichever account you choose, Detweiler cautions that “the most important tip is not to max out a new account. It’s perfectly fine to make small purchases and pay in full before the due date” to avoid paying interest or finance charges.
Pay off debt: Balance transfer cards
Balance transfer cards allow you to transfer balances from high-interest credit cards to an introductory 0% or very low rate card. These balance transfer credit cards are specifically designed to help consolidate and manage debt more efficiently by reducing interest costs. By moving high-interest balances to a lower-rate card, you can save money on interest payments during the promotional period, making it easier to pay down existing credit card balances. Minimizing interest charges is a key advantage of using balance transfer cards, which can ultimately save you a significant amount of money with a lower interest rate.
Finance purchases: Low-interest cards
If your goal is to extend your payments for a purchase without incurring interest charges, a low-interest-rate card is likely your best choice. These cards are ideal for financing major purchases while avoiding immediate interest costs. The annual percentage rate (APR) reflects the true cost of borrowing on a credit card if you carry a balance, so it’s important to compare interest rates when selecting a card for financing purchases.
Detweiler also highlights that a card with a long 0% purchase introductory APR (applicable to new purchases) can be a smart option. “If you can pay off that balance before the promotional period ends, you’ll enjoy interest-free financing on your purchases—sometimes for a year or more.”
Earn rewards: Cash back, travel rewards, points
Once your spending is under control and your credit is in good shape, a rewards credit card can help you earn valuable rebates on everyday purchases, such as points, miles, or cash back.
You generally have three main options:
- Cash back cards: These are the simplest, typically offering a fixed return that’s easy to track, such as a 2% cash back on all purchases. Daniels points out that earning cash back is a straightforward way to benefit from routine spending.
- Travel and points cards: These cards earn rewards usable toward flights, hotels, or other purchases. They sometimes include valuable perks like airport lounge access or travel protections, making them ideal for frequent travelers.
Some rewards cards offer extra rewards in specific categories like dining or online shopping. Daniels notes that regardless of whether a card is affiliated with one brand or is more flexible, the goal is the same: to earn rewards for purchases you would be making anyway.
Understand the costs and benefits of each card
How to evaluate annual fees
I’m generally not a fan of annual card fees and have rarely paid any during my lifetime. That said, many rewards and secured cards do charge annual fees, and paying an annual fee can sometimes be worth it. However, I strongly recommend conducting a thorough cost-benefit analysis before committing.
Daniels sums it up well:
“Annual fees can make sense, but only if the card’s benefits add value without creating extra spending. I don’t mind going out of my way to get value, but I’ve learned there’s a line between effort and cost. With one card, I found myself ordering food just to use a monthly dining credit — spending more than I would have otherwise and realizing the perk wasn’t actually improving my life in any way; it was costing me time and money.
“Simply put, the best perks are the ones that give you value for what you already do — not the ones that make you spend extra to justify them.”
Perks like insurance, protection, and lounge access
Many cards, particularly reward and premium cards like Visa Signature, come with less well-known benefits. Perks like trip cancellation coverage, lost luggage protection, extended warranties, or even cell phone insurance are common examples.
Daniels cautions, though, that “for frequent travelers, extras like lounge access or travel insurance can easily offset an annual fee if they’re benefits you’ll actually use. Airport lounge access is a valuable perk for frequent travelers, providing comfort and amenities during layovers. Some travel credit cards also offer priority boarding as an additional benefit, allowing you to board your flight earlier and secure overhead bin space. But if you travel less often, it may be more practical to choose a lower or no annual fee card and buy those protections when you need them.
“It’s not about how many perks a card has, but how useful they are in your real life. The right perks aren’t about quantity; they’re about fit.”
How to find the best credit card for you
Use comparison tools and marketplaces
Comparing credit cards lets you explore a wide range of options and filter them based on your goals, spending habits, and credit profile. This approach enables you to evaluate offers from various credit card companies and easily compare different cards and their features. While comparison tools are a great starting point, remember that the best credit card for you depends on your unique lifestyle, not just your credit score.
BONUS TIP!
Check out our Card Finder tool to help you compare cards quickly- results in as little as 60 seconds.
Check eligibility based on your credit score
Knowing your credit score ahead of time helps you select a credit card strategically. Different credit cards have varying credit requirements, so understanding where your credit scores stand is essential. Your FICO score plays a key role in determining your eligibility for premium credit cards. Be sure to check your score from all three major credit bureaus—Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion.
Daniels explains that “your credit score isn’t there to limit you – it’s there to guide you toward the cards that make sense for your current stage.”
Avoid applying for too many cards at once
Applying for a card is a normal part of building or rebuilding your credit. A hard inquiry can have a small, short-term negative effect on your credit score, but responsible use has a much bigger impact. Each application results in a hard inquiry on your credit report, which is reviewed by card issuers as part of the approval process. What matters most is that each card serves a clear purpose for how you spend.
Daniels recommends that consumers “apply with intention. Every card in your wallet should have a reason to be there.”
Conclusion: Choosing the right credit card
Selecting the best credit card comes down to understanding your lifestyle, spending habits, and financial goals. Whether you’re building credit with a secured or student card, managing debt with a balance transfer card, financing a big purchase with a low-interest card, or earning rewards with a cash back or travel rewards card, there’s an option tailored to your needs.
Remember to carefully evaluate card features, annual fees, interest rates, and rewards programs to ensure the card you choose offers real value without encouraging unnecessary spending. Keep your credit score in mind, and use comparison tools to find cards that fit your profile and goals.
By taking the time to match your spending patterns with the right card type, you’ll maximize benefits, minimize costs, and make smarter financial decisions. Ultimately, the best credit card is one that supports your lifestyle today and adapts as your financial needs evolve.
