Fed data shows split between debit card transaction costs

By , CardRatings contributor
  • Google +
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
Fed data shows split between debit card transaction costs

Most retailers now spend just 24 cents to process a debit card transaction, down from 43 cents in 2009, according to data released this month by the Federal Reserve Board. The Fed has stepped into a dispute between banks and retailers with statistics showing the impact of new interchange fee caps.

Under the terms of the Dodd-Frank Act, banks with more than $10 billion in assets must cap interchange fees on debit cards using a complex equation: "21 cents plus 0.05 percent multiplied by the value of the transaction, plus a 1-cent fraud-prevention adjustment, if eligible." Lawmakers and retail lobbyists clamored for the new rules, citing the benefits of less expensive debit card processing fees. However, loopholes in the regulations have infuriated some merchant trade organizations.

Debit card exemptions drive processing fees higher

For instance, American Express rolled out a line of prepaid debit cards that carry many of the same benefits as the company's traditional charge cards. Unlike Visa and Mastercard, AmEx operates its own, end-to-end payment processing platform, exempting the company from the debit card interchange fee cap.

The Fed's report shows that "exempt" debit card processing rates have remained steady, at 43 cents for a typical transaction in late 2011. Along with American Express, many government-issued debit cards also received exemptions. Merchant processors who previously offered discounted rates to fuel and grocery retailers brought their pricing schedules in line with government maximums, effectively raising processing costs for many merchants.

Merchants Payments Coalition counsel Douglas Kantor told Forbes magazine that banks and retailers dispute whether lower processing fees will even impact consumers. In Kantor's op-ed column, he accused banks of using "sleight of hand" to make shoppers believe that retailers have earned extra profits on high-profile sales categories, like gas and food. Using data from fuel and convenience retail trade organization NACS, Kantor suggested that local retailers using smaller banks could come off looking like "the bad guy" over time.

0 Responses to "Fed data shows split between debit card transaction costs"

No Comments

Leave a Comment
About Our Ratings ×

Our editors rate credit cards objectively based on the features the credit card offers consumers, the fees and interest rates, and how a credit card compares with other cards in its category. Ratings vary by category, and the same card may receive a certain number of stars in one category and a higher or lower number in another.

The ratings are the expert opinion of our editors, and not influenced by any remuneration this site may receive from card issuers.

Advertisers in our database are highlighted, and advertisements include an option to apply using links on our site. CardRatings.com may be compensated by companies mentioned on the site when a user's application is accepted or approved by such companies.

How do your cards stack up?

Compare your card starting here


Featured Partner Cards